Sports

Three Division III athletes sue the NCAA over its ban on athletic scholarships

Three Division III athletes sue the NCAA over its ban on athletic scholarships at more than 400 universities. The case defines the cost of developing athletic talent.

Tribuna vacía de un estadio universitario, demanda NCAA becas deportivas

Three NCAA Division III athletes filed an antitrust class action on October 23, 2026, in the United States District Court for the Central District of California. They seek to strike down the rule that bans athletic scholarships at more than 400 universities and are asking for treble damages under Section 4 of the Clayton Act.

The plaintiffs are Jackson Hale, a defensive back at Pacific Lutheran; Connor Printz, a former basketball player at Claremont McKenna; and Chris Jennings, a former swimmer and lacrosse player at the University of Lynchburg, according to The Big Lead. The suit challenges Rule 15.01.3, which bars institutions in the division from awarding financial aid based on athletic ability or performance. For an operator that sells recruiting, eligibility or financing services to universities, the central question is who absorbs the cost of developing athletes: the institution, the sponsor or the student. In Division III, the rule removes the athletic scholarship from that equation.

The proposed class covers athletes who competed from October 21, 2022, a four-year statute of limitations window, and the NCAA's exposure is calculated on the roughly 210,000 athletes who compete each year in the association's largest division, according to Sportico. Printz, who left the team at the start of the 2023-24 season, says he took on debt to cover about 80,000 dollars in tuition, housing and food, and that he earned as much as 50,000 dollars in name, image and likeness deals with Reebok and Clif Bar. The legal team is led by Michael Goldberg, co-lead counsel in Ray v. NCAA. The argument rests on NCAA v. Alston, the unanimous Supreme Court ruling in 2021, and must get past Rock v. NCAA, which in 2013 dismissed equivalent claims on the view that the ban is presumably procompetitive.

The outcome will define the size of the recruiting, eligibility and school sponsorship market in the most populous division of American college sports, and it sets a precedent that LatAm operators selling services to universities will watch closely. The next date to watch is the NCAA's response to the complaint.

This article was drafted with the assistance of artificial intelligence from verified sources and reviewed by a human editor before publication.

Sources